Scalecoat I vs. II: Choosing Model Paint and Thinner
Choosing Scalecoat model paint starts with the model's material, then the color and finish you want. A brass locomotive, a styrene freight-car shell and a mixed-material structure can require different decisions. Use this guide to narrow the choices before buying paint, thinner and clear coats.
Browse Scalecoat model railroad paint, primers and clear coats at South Plains Trains. Check each listing for its exact series, color, size, part number and current availability.
Scalecoat I or Scalecoat II?
Scalecoat identifies both lines as solvent-based model paints. The practical distinction is their intended surface: Scalecoat I is primarily for brass and metal, while Scalecoat II is designed for plastic, including styrene. Do not use Scalecoat I on plastic.
| Paint series | Primary application | Matching thinner |
|---|---|---|
| Scalecoat I | Brass and metal models | Scalecoat I Thinner |
| Scalecoat II | Plastic and styrene models | Scalecoat II Thinner |
For an unfamiliar resin, coating or other material, confirm compatibility before committing to a complete repaint. A test on a spare part is more useful than assuming that every material behaves like styrene. On a model containing several materials, identify the surface of each part you intend to paint.
Choose the Color and Part Number Together
Make a short paint list for the project: body color, roof, underframe, trucks, handrails and any contrasting panels. Record the paint series and manufacturer part number beside each color. This makes it easier to reorder a specific bottle or spot a mistaken selection before checkout.
For a railroad paint scheme, use reference photographs and reliable information about the particular locomotive or car. A railroad name alone may not describe the shade used on every piece of equipment or at every date. Weathering, repairs and lighting also affect the appearance you are trying to reproduce.
Keep similar names separate. “Boxcar Red” and a numbered variation should not be treated as interchangeable just because both suit a freight-car project. Compare the exact listing, then keep your chosen part numbers with the model's build notes.
Plan the Finish Before Painting
Color and sheen are separate choices. Flat finishes have little visible shine, satin gives a softer sheen, and gloss produces a shinier surface. Choose the appearance you want for the finished model, including whether the project represents freshly painted equipment or a weathered working locomotive.
Read the individual product's finish description. Do not assume that every Scalecoat color is gloss, or that a clear coat and a pigmented paint serve the same purpose. If decals and weathering are part of the project, plan their order and the final clear finish before spraying the first color. Test the complete combination on a spare surface, including the clear coat.
Match the Thinner to the Paint Series
Use Scalecoat I Thinner with Scalecoat I paint, and Scalecoat II Thinner with Scalecoat II paint. Buy the thinner for the series actually in your cart. Follow current container directions for thinning and application; a single mixing ratio is not a substitute for checking the paint and equipment you are using.
Put the paint, matching thinner and intended clear finish together on your project list. It is easier to catch a mismatched bottle there than when the model is already disassembled and ready for paint.
A Practical Preparation Sequence
- Identify and inspect the parts. Separate the components you need to paint and check their material.
- Prepare the surface. Follow the manufacturer's cleaning guidance and let the parts dry before painting.
- Test the system. Try the paint and planned finishing steps on a spare part or inconspicuous area.
- Apply controlled coats. Follow the current label and application guidance for your method and equipment.
- Allow sufficient drying time. Check the directions before handling, masking, recoating or adding decals.
Use proper ventilation and follow the container's safety instructions. Keep a small record of the products and settings that worked for your model so the next project is easier to repeat.
Common Scalecoat Questions
Is Scalecoat a Lacquer or an Enamel?
The manufacturer's current clarification describes both series as solvent-based model paints and says neither is a traditional lacquer. Choose by the intended material and product instructions rather than relying on an older lacquer-versus-enamel shorthand.
Can I Choose a Paint by Bottle Size Alone?
No. Size tells you how much product the bottle contains, not which surface or finish it suits. Check the series, exact color, finish and part number as well.
What Shipping Should I Expect?
Scalecoat's current supplier shipping policy specifies UPS Ground to physical street addresses within the contiguous 48 United States. It excludes Alaska, Hawaii, territories, international destinations and APO/FPO addresses. Standard P.O. boxes are not supported. See the product page and checkout for availability and shipping charges; processing time is separate from carrier transit time.
Shop the Scalecoat paint selection and compare the specific products for your next model railroad project.